All Posts

Design Your Own MABR

Design Your Own MABR

Have you always wanted an MABR for your Wastewater Treatment Plant but feel overwhelmed by where to start?

  • What do you need?

  • What will it look like?

  • How much membrane is required?

  • How much air is required?

Well let's start at the beginning, and like other aeration technologies the first thing that must be calculated is how much oxygen is required for the biological treatment process? Pollution in wastewater is either particulate (solids) or dissolved. While biological processes can treat both, for ease of calculation, and because biological processes take a lot longer to break down solid components than settling or filtration, we will only consider the dissolved components in this calculation.

Oxygen will be required for the breakdown of Carbon Oxygen Demand (COD)  and Ammonia:

  • 1kg of O2 for every kg of COD
  • 4.6kg of O2 for every kg of Ammonia as N (N-NH3)

Oxygen Demandshutterstock_361870004.jpg

For a typical municipal wastewater post primary treatment plant the concentrations are:

  • Dissolved or Soluble COD:      300mg/l
  • Ammonia as Nitrogen:    50mg/l

Multiplying these concentrations by the flowrate gives the total oxygen demand required kgO2 per day.  In the following example we will use a daily flowrate of 1000m3/day.

Screen Shot 2016-11-04 at 12.55.19.png

Table 1: Typical Inlet Wastewater Concentrations for 5,000 Population Equivalent

Screen Shot 2016-11-04 at 15.55.44.png

 

Membrane Requirements

Once the Oxygen requirement is known, the next question is how much gas permeable membrane is required to supply this O2? Taking an average Oxygen Transfer Rate (OTR) of 10gO2 /m2 of membrane per day gives a membrane requirement of:

Screen Shot 2016-11-04 at 12.55.27.png

Table 2: Calculation of Membrane Surface Area Required for Oxygen Delivery

Screen Shot 2016-11-03 at 16.22.25.png

Air Requirement and Energy

The oxygen must be provided to the system and to do this air is supplied to the lumen of the hollow fibres membranes. Assuming an Oxygen Transfer Efficiency (OTE) of 50% and an oxygen concentration in the air of 21%, the air requirement is 150 Nm3/h at a pressure of 200mBar. The air supply pressure is independent of the water depth in the tank and as the air does not leave the membrane, pressure is required only to overcome the pressure loss due to airflow in the hollow fibre membranes.

The energy required to supply this air can be calculated using the Equation 4 which is taken from Metcalf and Eddy (2002), for the energy requirement for a blower, in this case using a blower efficiency of 0.65, give a power requirement of 1.25kW.

Screen Shot 2016-11-04 at 12.55.38.png

Table 3: Flow Rate of Air required

Screen Shot 2016-11-03 at 16.24.12.png

What Else is Needed?

1 . Tank

A tank of some sort is required to hold the liquid to be treated. This tank can be an existing tank e.g storm water tank, clarification tank or activated sludge tank.  The volume of the tank will depend on the packing density of the membranes. A packing density of 400-500m2/m3 is recommended.

The MABR tank can be operated in one of two modes:

  • A completely mixed system where the detached biofilm and the solids are kept suspended in the liquid. These solids can then be separated from the liquid in a subsequent solids liquid separation process e.g. Settler, Dissolved Air Flotation (DAF) or Filter press
  • Alternatively settling of the solids can take place directly in the tank with the MABR modules. If this is required then a settled sludge extractions system is required from the bottom of the tank. This could be a mechanical system or use the hydraulic head above the settled sludge to force it into a series of sludge extraction pipes.

The removed or separated sludge can then be further thickened or processed to increase the Solids Concentrations.

  1. Mixing

Because there are no bubbles for aeration, an alternative source of mixing is required. Mixing is crucial in an MABR to ensure that the biofilm which is attached to the membrane gets in contact with the wastewater. General principles state that the mixing time for a Continuous Stirred Tank Reactor should be 10% to 20% the residence time of the reactor. Therefore the shorter the residence time the shorter the mixing time, and the more energy that is required for mixing.

Mixing also becomes more crucial at lower concentrations, as at low concentrations the rate of reaction is directly related to the concentration, and if a large stagnant layer of water develops over the surface of the biofilm due to poor or non-uniform mixing it will significantly reduce the rate of reaction and not make effective use of the biofilm. Additionally poor mixing may lead to short circuiting in the reactor. Oxymem has developed a number of clever ways of mixing an MABR, utilising the momentum of the flow as well as low energy air lift systems reusing the exhaust gas from the hollow fibre membrane.

  1. Biofilm Control

While the first stage of an MABR processes is transferring Oxygen across the membrane, the next step is the consumption by the Biofilm of both the Oxygen and the pollutants. Therefore it is important to not only make sure there is enough biomass but also that the biomass is not too thick. If the biomass becomes too thick then the rate of diffusion of Oxygen and pollutants through the biofilm becomes the rate limiting step. Therefore periodically the biofilm should be scoured to remove excess biofilm and to maintain its optimal thickness.  An OxyMem MABR has an air-scour grid in the base, and scouring with coarse air bubbles takes only a few minutes, with a frequency dependant on the growth rate of the biofilm

  1. Screening

Finally, good screening is important for all wastewater treatment plants. Debris such as branches, wires or ropes can get tangled with the membranes and potentially damage the hollow fibres. Ragging or hairs are not an issue in the MABR, as no filtration is taking place these solids are not pulled towards the membranes and so do not cause any issues. But additionally they are not removed by the MABR and will become part of whatever solids are removed, post biological treatment.

Nomenclature

Screen Shot 2016-11-04 at 13.01.14.png


Summary

MABR holds out the very real possibility of having a transformative impact on the way we plan, manage and operate wastewater infrastructure.  The principal  benefits are 75% Energy saving, 50% less sludge, in a greatly reduced footprint (Up to 80% reduction). Don't you owe it to yourself and your organisation to investigate further? Please try our MABR design tool for sizing your applications....

 


 

Subscribe to stay informed

*Environment  *Legislation  *Socio-economics  *Technology

Related Posts

H20 Global News -An Interview with OxyMem Managing Director Andreas Gorenflo

Exclusive Interview with OxyMem H2O Global News' Editor, Natasha Posnett, caught up with Andreas Gorenflo, our Managing Director at OxyMem, to get a better understanding of what we offer and how OxyMem helps customers worldwide. Also discussed in the interview is the role MABR plays in ensuring water sector sustainability.  

OxyMem MABR Technology Helps Wastewater Treatment Plant in Lanzhou, China

OxyMem MABR Technology Helps Wastewater Treatment Plant in Lanzhou, China Breakthrough biological treatment technology deployed to help improve water quality of the Yellow River  

Nitrous Oxide, Not So Funny After All

Nitrous Oxide, Not So Funny After All   Nitrous oxide emissions from wastewater treatment plants are 265 times more harmful to our environment than carbon dioxide. Nitrous oxide (N2O), a greenhouse gas which is emitted as an undesired bioproduct during the biological treatment of wastewater,  it is estimated to be responsible for six per cent of global greenhouse gas emissions, and it has a warming potential 265 times that of carbon dioxide (CO2). It is also one of the main contributors to depleting the ozone layer. The gas is created during the nitrification and denitrification phase due to nitrogen present in urea, ammonia, and proteins found in municipal wastewater. Despite these concerns, there is some reason for optimism because nitrous oxide has a much shorter lifespan of only 114 years compared to carbon dioxide, which can survive hundreds of years in the atmosphere. Therefore, making changes to reduce N2O emission can have a profound effect on the environment in a much shorter time frame. A report from 2019 showed that 6% of nitrous oxide emissions in the United States come from wastewater treatment. Given this prevalence, reducing, and mitigating process emissions from N2O will be paramount for the water industry over the coming decade. Currently the water industry is working towards monitoring nitrous oxide on treatment plants and considering how best to reduce emissions through optimization or upgrading of treatment processes. Could OxyMem be the answer? Investing in technologies which can limit emission and make plant activities more sustainable will be key. To date there has been significant interest in carbon emissions within the sector, but momentum is growing as interest shifts towards targeting harmful nitrous oxide and lesser-known greenhouse gases.  Denmark  In 2018 the Danish EPA launched a funding scheme for Danish utility companies dedicated to measurements of and mitigation actions towards nitrous oxide emissions. In the period from 2018 to 2020, nine Danish utilities have measured and registered nitrous oxide emissions from nine different wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) under the EPA funding scheme OxyMem have supported Vandcenter Syd (VCS) Denmark, who partnered with Aarhus Vand Denmark, to demonstrate the benefits of MABR technology at the Ejby Mølle WWRF. Work started in the summer of 2018. The full-scale demonstration of MABR at Ejby Mølle provided some great insights into the technology, but one key aspect recorded was the significant difference in N2O emissions from MABR when compared against conventional activated sludge treatment. In this project VCS measured nitrous oxide emissions from the conventional activated sludge surface-aerated reactors and the MABR demonstration reactors. Liquid phase sensors were positioned in both the existing activated sludge tanks and the demonstration MABR tanks, and a gas analyser was used to measure nitrous oxide concentrations in the exhaust gas of the MABR units. Results showed that nitrous oxide emissions were on average one order of magnitude lower than those from the conventional activated sludge plant, even under much higher loading conditions. The initial results from the project are very promising and reflect the immense potential for MABR to achieve very intensive total nitrogen removal with low nitrous oxide emissions. United Kingdom -2030 Net Zero Goals Given the potential for the sector, further studies on N2O and the added benefits of MABR are to be formally carried out under a recent initiative by Anglian Water. OxyMem technology was chosen to demonstrate how MABR might help the UK achieve 2030 emissions goals. Plant design is already underway. The project will be funded through an Innovation Fund made available by Ofwat Anglian Water’s Triple Carbon Reduction solution, delivered in partnership with OxyMem, Element Energy Ltd, Jacobs, Cranfield University, University of East Anglia, Brunel University, Severn Trent Water, Scottish Water, Northern Ireland Water and United Utilities, has been awarded more than £3.5 million. It will use novel technologies to target a step change reduction in greenhouse gas emissions and electricity use in used water treatment and provide a new renewable energy source through green hydrogen production – 'triple carbon' synergy and contribution towards achieving net zero carbon emissions by 2030. Adam Brookes, Manager of Innovation Discovery, Anglian Water, said: “Funding for this project will greatly support the delivery of our own net zero routemap and the water sector's drive to Net Zero by 2030, filling a significant missing piece in the challenge. By collaborating with academia, businesses and other water companies, our project creates an elegant solution to eliminate part of the greenhouse gas emissions associated with wastewater treatment and position the sector within the developing hydrogen landscape, in line with the newly launched UK Government Hydrogen strategy.” Amanda Lake, Water Process Lead, Jacobs Europe, said: “We’re excited to couple an innovative pure MABR treatment solution with green hydrogen production. We know the outcomes could be significant for the water sector - lower nitrous oxide process emissions, a role in the green hydrogen economy, valuable resource recovery and application of best practice life cycle assessment methods. What a valuable chance to work together to open the door to the lower carbon, circular economy water sector we urgently require. OxyMem MABR technology could assist the sector in achieving their global environmental goals over the coming years, by enhancing current Wastewater Treatment Plants capacity and at same time help clients move towards achieving their future net zero carbon emissions.  OxyMem MABR enables clients to add or improve ammonia reduction on existing large works using only a few kW's, and the technology can be simply dropped into existing treatment plants without the need to build additional structures or stopping live processes which are key benefits to enable the sector to achieve global environmental goals over the coming years.